#29815
Jimmy-T
Keymaster

    I may be splitting hairs here but section 102 doesn’t make any reference to a “budget” but instead refers to items for which estimates have been provided to an AGM:

    An owners corporation for a large strata scheme must not spend on an item or matter an amount greater than the amount specified for the item or matter (plus 10%) in estimates provided for that item or matter at an annual general meeting.

    So there are two issues there – it’s estimates rather than budgetted items and it’s an AGM, specifically, rather than any other general meeting.

    Now you might reasonably assume that items discussed at an AGM and for which estimates have been provided might be part of the budget.  But not necessarily.

    If, for instance, an owner proposes a motion to spend an amount on, say, painting and that isn’t in the budget, it would come under the 10 per cent limit.

    However, if that proposal comes up in the middle of the year between AGMs and is made to the strata committee rather than the AGM, there may be no such restriction.

    Apart from the limit on a figure above which two estimates must be sought ($30,000 in a large scheme), and legal fees, there doesn’t seem to be any other restrictions on spending in either the Act or the Regulations.

    So where does that leave unbudgetted items? I don’t think there is any legal requirement to only spend money on items identified in the budget so the 10 per cent excess limit (and its waiver) applies only to items discussed at the AGM.

    Apart from that, it would seem that the committee, if it has been given the power to act on behalf of the owners corporation, can spend whatever it wants on whatever it wishes and face the consequences at the next AGM. 

    So I am going with Waratah’s mate, but not for the reasons specified. The 10 per cent rule would not apply to expenditure that’s not in the budget or discussed at the AGM – because it never applied in the first place.

    The opinions offered in these Forum posts and replies are not intended to be taken as legal advice. Readers with serious issues should consult experienced strata lawyers.