Good old Member [name removed], the man with the magic bow-tie and the famous smokin’ case.
I would say two things.
Nothing an adjudicator says (or a Member) creates a precedent, i.e. decisons do not bind other adjudicators or Members, and [this member] made some real howlers in his time, was the case referred to one of them.
It would be interesting to see if CTTT wanted to be consistent on smoking matters.
Having said that i will butt out.