#24639
Sir Humphrey
Strataguru

    Unusually, I am inclined to agree with Austman rather than Jimmy T. Yes, the OC has to maintain the gutter whether it was well maintained previously or not. However, if there was no negligence or defect of the common property because the gutter had been well maintained, I don’t see how the OC is liable to pay for the car owner’s bad luck in a storm.