• Creator
    Topic
  • #12097
    fandoog
    Flatchatter

      I live in a block of units which have a variety of shaped and sizes of unit, and four of them have expansive terraces that are highly visible from the buildings on either side of us. One of these unit owners asked the Strata Committee for permission to erect some privacy screens on which they wished to grow floral arrays, and permission was duly granted and flowers grown. Six screens were bolted onto the brick balustrade, which is common property, and all was fine, until the tenants in another unit objected saying that the screens blocked their view and ruined their lives. They have since moved out. The owners of that unit have asked for the screens to be removed, and claimed that it is difficult to get tenants with part of the view blocked. However, the owners of the screens have invested some considerable money in buying the screens and having tradesmen bolt them to the building, which they did with Strata permission as far as they were concerned. The screens are patterned, about 2 metres tall, and are in a row along the balustrade that is perpendicular to the unit that is objecting.

      Our committee changed and a new person became Secretary recently, and as she is friends with the owners of the unit objecting to the screens has started a process of stating that this is a “major renovation” requiring a special resolution, and is worrying the hell out of the people who installed the screens. She wants to hold an EGM to get a vote done to give or deny permission.

      Can this occur. Do the owners of the screens, who acted in good faith and who do need some privacy have to subjected to what is in effect a retrospective decision by this new Secretary, and is a Special resolution required.

      As we also have some special by-laws about renovations, a by law is required to do any renovation, so we get into the territory of requirements for a DA, drawings, costs etc, all to have something to grow flowers on.

      The location is somewhat exposed, and can be hit by violent southerly winds at times, which is why the screens need to be bolted down, although they could possibly be made to be self supporting and so not permanently attached to common property. Are there restrictions on what we can grow on our terraces. Could they grow a bamboo hedge in pots for example?It’s not visible from the street, only from the one unit that is making the objection, and the units in the building next door, all able to look straight on to said terrace.

    Viewing 2 replies - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
    • Author
      Replies
    • #30940
      Lady Penelope
      Strataguru

        The new Secretary is correct in stating that the privacy screens are a Major Renovation. They would clearly be impacting the external appearance of the building. 

        https://www.fairtrading.nsw.gov.au/housing-and-property/strata-and-community-living/strata-schemes/renovations

        The original approval should not have been given by the Committee as they had no authority to issue this approval.

        There are many different ways to create privacy that do not include fixed panels.

        With regard to plants on balconies – what do your by-laws say about this issue? Planting a hedge of bamboo would also impact on the external appearance of a building so be mindful of that issue too.

        Planting bamboo in heavy pots may also impact on structural weight limitations for the balcony and the overall safety of the building.

        One lot owner’s objection to the use and enjoyment of their Lot being adversely affected by the actions of another Lot owner is just as valid as several lot owner’s objections. The Act is designed to protect the rights of all Lot owners, whether they are in the minority or are in the majority. The protection of these ‘minority’ rights are available via the doctrine of fraud on a power, and this doctrine is recognised by the Supreme Court.  

        #30952
        fandoog
        Flatchatter
        Chat-starter

          Thanks Lady Penelope, You sound like you know your stuff. You say that “There are many different ways to create privacy that do not include fixed panels.” Can you suggest some that may not be as heavy as a bamboo hedge?

          Every one of the terraces has plants on them and no weight limits have ever been seen. We even have a couple that already have privacy screens on them, so to single out this particular instance may be seen as victimisation. If one lot of screens and plants is banned, then the whole building will have to get rid of all of them. Am I right? 

          It’s beyond my understanding of the interpretation of the law, and beyond that of the manager as well it seems, as his advice when this started was pretty unsure. I’d love your opinion back on this. Thanks.

        Viewing 2 replies - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
        • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.