I’m in Sydney, in an older block which has at least three large, mature shade trees at the front, but only one at the back, my side of the block. The former OC committee chair decided to have it cut down, as it was taking too much water from the pipes or some other excuse – none of the residents, both owners and tenants were told about it, and I only realised what was happening when I saw the chainsaws at work. I took the OC to NCAT (the Chair wouldn’t answer any questions and I also pointed out that she was breach of Ryde Council’s rules that trees chopped down must be replaced to similar height and species. It took NCAT to force the OC to replant, which unwillingly, they did. And I’m careful to keep both eyes open and water them – three were planted in the end- regularly.
Take the case to NCAT – it’s worth it. Oh, and I also realised that SM will follow directions from OCs without question even if they know it’s inappropriate or bordering on the illegal.