I just love a lively debate and this issue is close to my heart. I bought my apartment because it was pet friendly, however on the first day I moved in my neighbour and EC member curtly told me 'no dogs were allowed'. This EC member backed down when I told her I was the owner and that when I checked there were no bylaws in place. They had recently just made this rule prior to me moving in. So in short I applied to the EC and got permission (of sorts) I believe you should have it in writing? I have asked for this in writing but gave up 2 years ago when I moved out.
Many dogs these days live in apartments. Its a fact of life. Our dog never barked, she is a city apartment dog and is quiet and doesnt shred hair. Non issue – never has been. We now live in a huge house on 5 acres, guess what? she is still an inside dog and always will be.
You cant make judgements about people and their pets. I agree some can be a nightmare, but dog friendly buildings can add value to property. People are willing to pay that little bit more if they know that there dog is welcome.