› Forums › Living in strata › Current Page

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #86214 Reply | Quote
    Flatchatter
    Flatchatter

      If an EC member writes to Strata Manager to accuse a resident of (a) Walking gardeners around the property (b) instructing them and (c) supervising their work, and then the Resident receives an email effectively transmitting those accusations, is there anything stopping the Strata Manager from calling the resident to get their side of the story – ALL of the accusations are false

    Viewing 11 replies - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
    • Author
      Replies
    • #86216 Reply
      FlatChatBot
      Strataguru

        There is nothing stopping the strata manager from calling the resident to get their side of the story. In fact, it’s good practice for a strata manager to clarify facts and seek input from all parties before taking any action or making a decision. Strata managers are expected to act fairly and with due diligence, and resolving disputes often starts with clear communication and fact-finding from everyone involved. If you feel you have been wrongly accused, you should respond to the strata manager to provide your version of events and ask for clarification on how they intend to proceed.

        More information on resolving disputes can be found here: strata disputes.

        #86217 Reply
        Flatchatter
        Flatchatter
        Chat-starter

          I did (yes – I am the resident) and I was told that “I understand that you would have preferred that I give you a call before writing to you. However, I do need to take reports from committee members seriously, and when a concern is raised I need to ensure it is followed up and that there is a written record of it. As strata manager, I am employed by the owners corporation and take instructions from the strata committee, so if I am requested to issue correspondence like this, I must attend to it.”

          #86218 Reply
          FlatChatBot
          Strataguru

            The strata manager is correct that they are required to act on instructions from the owners corporation or strata committee, and to keep a written record of correspondence for transparency and accountability. However, you are entitled to respond and provide your side of the story, and the strata manager should consider your response as part of their due diligence. If you feel you have been unfairly treated or that the process is being misused, you can raise your concerns with the strata committee or seek mediation through NSW Fair Trading if the issue escalates.

            You can read more about dispute resolution and the responsibilities of strata managers here:

            General information only, not legal advice.

            #86219 Reply
            FlatChatBot
            Strataguru

              BUT she is refusing to call me to verify or get my side -she suggests she is NOT able to call before taking any action including sending on the untested, not investigated accusations

              #86220 Reply
              FlatChatBot
              Strataguru

                There is nothing in NSW strata law that prevents a strata manager from calling a resident to clarify or verify an accusation before sending formal correspondence. However, strata managers are required to act on instructions from the owners corporation or strata committee, and often prefer to keep a written record of communications for accountability.

                While it is reasonable for a strata manager to document complaints, best practice would involve giving you an opportunity to respond before any further action is taken. If you feel the process is unfair or that your side is not being considered, you can raise this with the strata committee or seek mediation through NSW Fair Trading if needed. More details are here: Strata disputes.

                General information only, not legal advice.

                #86221 Reply
                FlatChatBot
                Strataguru

                  OK but in this case, ALL references to committees boil down to one person – the one making the accusations

                  #86222 Reply
                  FlatChatBot
                  Strataguru

                    If your strata committee consists of only one active member who is making the accusations, this can be problematic, especially if there’s no independent review or checks in place. While the strata manager must act on instructions from the committee, they also have a duty to act fairly and with due diligence. If you believe the process is being misused by a single individual, you can raise your concerns in writing to the strata manager, request that your response be formally recorded, and ask for the matter to be discussed at a full owners corporation meeting.

                    If this doesn’t resolve the issue, you can seek mediation through NSW Fair Trading: Strata disputes.

                    General information only, not legal advice.

                    #86223 Reply
                    FlatChatBot
                    Strataguru

                      Our Scheme’s committee consists of 3 people one of which is my partner who was not included and one other who was also NOT included

                      #86224 Reply
                      FlatChatBot
                      Strataguru

                        If the strata manager is acting on instructions from just one committee member, without involving the other committee members, this is not proper process. Decisions and actions should be made by the majority of the committee, not by a single member acting alone. All committee members should be consulted or have the opportunity to be involved in committee decisions, especially before making accusations or sending formal correspondence to residents.

                        You and the other committee member who were excluded should raise this concern with the strata manager in writing and request that all committee members be included in future decisions and communications. If this continues, you can escalate the issue to the owners corporation or seek assistance from NSW Fair Trading: Strata disputes.

                        General information only, not legal advice.

                        #86227 Reply
                        Flatchatter
                        Flatchatter
                        Chat-starter

                          So, no reason why strata manager could not just call me before writing any damn emails, even if only to me

                          #86233 Reply
                          Jimmy-T
                          Keymaster

                            What’s missing here is the email from the strata manager.  Given that it was sent only to the OP, and that simple act offers an opportunity to respond and correct the record, this is clearly a personal dispute between two owners. The answer is to write to the committee and ask its members when they held a meeting that decided to involve the strata manager, and write to the manager correcting the allegations and asking that the response be conveyed to the committee.  But really, the committee should be telling its members not to use the strata manager as a proxy in their squabbles with other owners.

                          Viewing 11 replies - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
                          Reply To: Reply #86219 in False report to strata manager
                          PLEASE ... If your property is not in NSW, mention its location (state). Don't identify companies or individuals by name. Don't mention or promote your company or services. Keep acronyms and initials to a minimum. Please, don’t use “quote” unless there is a specific point to which you wish to refer, then highlight (define) that specific passage before you click on "quote". Otherwise just use reply. THANKS.

                          You can use BBCodes to format your content.
                          Your account can't use all available BBCodes, they will be stripped before saving.

                          Your information:




                          › Forums › Living in strata › Current Page