› Forums › The Professionals › SCs and strata managers › Current Page

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #86252 Reply | Quote
    SJ1965
    Flatchatter

      Hi all,

      We’re in a bit of a pickle with our strata manager and would appreciate some advice.

      We’ve been dealing with ongoing issues involving inconsistent advice from our strata manager for over 12 months.

      More recently, we discovered several inaccuracies and omissions in our building insurance underwriting. The strata manager is attempting to shift responsibility onto owners for not declaring modifications, despite some of the information being available in the OC’s historical records.

      The EC is now proposing to appoint a new strata manager at our upcoming AGM.

      We’ve submitted motions with explanatory notes outlining the reasons for the proposed change. However, our current strata manager is refusing to include the explanations because they disagree with the criticisms of their management.

      Here’s where it gets interesting.

      While refusing to include our comments in the AGM notice, the strata manager took it upon themselves to email all owners directly, advising that the EC was proposing a new manager, naming the proposed replacement company, and then promoting their own services and reasons for remaining as our manager.

      So apparently they can communicate directly with owners to defend themselves, but the EC can’t include its reasons for proposing a change in the AGM documentation.

      We’ve asked them to identify any legislative or procedural reason for excluding the explanatory notes, but so far haven’t received a clear answer.

      We’re now considering our options, including taking the matter to ACAT or potentially conducting the AGM ourselves.

      Has anyone dealt with a strata manager refusing to include motions or explanatory notes they disagree with?

      Can the strata manager actually prevent the EC from including this information, particularly when some owners will be voting by absentee ballot?

      Any advice or experiences would be appreciated.

    Viewing 1 replies (of 1 total)
    • Author
      Replies
    • #86256 Reply
      Jimmy-T
      Keymaster

        I think the answer is quite simple – send your own explanation to owners directly and include an expalantion that the strata manager refused to pass on your observations.

        Schedule 1.2 of the ACT Unit Titles act sets out clear guidelines for strata managers, especially Secion 8 (1), (3) and (4):

        8 Unconscionable conduct

        A manager must not engage in unconscionable conduct in carrying out the manager’s functions.

        1 taking unfair advantage of the manager’s superior knowledge relative to the owners corporation

        3 improperly using the executive member’s position on the executive committee to gain, directly or indirectly, an advantage personally or for someone else

        4 exerting undue influence on, or using unfair tactics against, the owners corporation or the owner of a unit in the units plan.

        So let’s assume the strata manager refuses to hand over the Register, or the register doesn’t have owners’ email addresses but the strata manager does and they refuse to hand them over on grounds of privacy. My non-lawyer reading of the Privacy Act is that if your scheme has an annual turnover of less than $3million then (I think) the Privacy Act’s provisions on personal information don’t apply.

        So let’s assume the strata manager still refuses to hand over the email addresses or pass on your message to the owners, they may have then breached Schedule 1.2 (8) on three counts. They’ve taken unfair advantage of superior knowledge. If they are on the executive committee, they have improperly used their position to gain an advantage personally.  They have exerted “undue influence on, or using unfair tactics against, the owners corporation.”

        So my tactic would be to ask them to immediately send out your email or provide you with the owners email addresses, or face the consequences.  The next step would probably be to seek mediation or, if that fails,  make a complaint to ACAT.

        Your proposed  replacement strata manager may advise you on the nuts and bolts of making a complaint, but the fact that you have a plan and you seem to know what you’re doing may be enough to get the SM to toe the line.

        Beari n mind that you may have to tone down the compaint you are sending out to owners. Keep it simple and don’t get involved in “he said – she said” confrontations. Just telling owners that the relationship with the strata manager has broken down and it’s time to move on may be enough.

         

      Viewing 1 replies (of 1 total)
      Reply To: Reply #86256 in Major strata manager issue
      PLEASE ... If your property is not in NSW, mention its location (state). Don't identify companies or individuals by name. Don't mention or promote your company or services. Keep acronyms and initials to a minimum. Please, don’t use “quote” unless there is a specific point to which you wish to refer, then highlight (define) that specific passage before you click on "quote". Otherwise just use reply. THANKS.

      You can use BBCodes to format your content.
      Your account can't use all available BBCodes, they will be stripped before saving.

      Your information:




      › Forums › The Professionals › SCs and strata managers › Current Page