› Forums › Common Property › Current Page

  • This topic has 0 replies, 1 voice, and was last updated 7 minutes ago by -.
  • Creator
    Topic
  • #86014 Reply | Quote
    Jimmy-T
    Keymaster

      I am reproducing this in this one post because it is long and complicated.  Is it a prank?  I’m not sure but I don’t think so.  However, the amazing thing is the Flat Chatbot hung in there and offered good and, importantly, empathic advice (although it does say “I’m sorry” a lot).  And how did it almost “break” the chatbot?  It used up a whole chunk of my free questions allowance.  But that’s Okay, I didnt realise I had a limit and now I’ve switched to a chatbot platform that doesn’t have one  Result!

      Anyway, this saga is about a pensioner in Queensland whose allocated car spot has been taken from her by her committee chair and she can’t get it back.

      READER: I am being ignored by my strata manager and bullied

      FLAT CHATBOT: Hi, I’m an AI guide to Flat Chat’s strata articles and other essential sources for strata-living information. I’m sorry you’re dealing with this. To point you to relevant guidance, which state or territory are you in, and are you an owner or renter? Is your concern mainly about strata rules or your tenancy?

      READER: Queensland state, I am an owner and paying very high levies

      FLAT CHATBOT: I’m sorry you’re dealing with this. Flat Chat’s Queensland article discusses concerns about long-term management contracts, but it is commentary—not legal advice and not a guide to whether your particular levies are reasonable: Queensland owners fight 25-year strata contracts

      Could you tell me what you most need help with: understanding how the levies were set, getting a response from the strata manager, or dealing with the bullying? You don’t need to share names or your building’s address. General information only, not legal advice.

      READER: I am paying very high levies because my lot came with exclusive car space right which was stolen and given to another lot few months before I bought it without my knowledge and without adjusting the contribution entitlements down. I tried to resolve this with the current body corporate manager and committee but they just ignore me and now she told me they do no want to correspond with me. I am devastated as I am charged very high levies with no right to my car space

      FLAT CHATBOT: I’m so sorry—being ignored while facing a substantial financial concern would be deeply upsetting. I can’t tell from this information whether the car-space right or contribution entitlements were changed validly; that depends on the scheme documents and records. Flat Chat’s Queensland commentary discusses Queensland body corporate complexities, but it is opinion, not a guide to your specific rights or current law.

      A practical next step is to gather your title and sale documents and request the relevant scheme records, including the registered plan, any exclusive-use by-law and the contribution schedule. For current Queensland guidance, contact the Queensland Government’s body corporate information service or call 1800 060 119. Because this involves property rights and significant levies, consider getting advice from a Queensland strata lawyer before deciding what to do next.

      READER: I am suffering because I have been doing a lot of investigation for a number of years and got evidence and tried to meet with the body corporate manager to show her and try to self resolve it because that is what the bccm expect but she just ignored me and now don’t want to correspond with me

      FLAT CHATBOT: I’m sorry—years of investigating this and then being told they won’t correspond with you sounds exhausting and isolating. You’ve tried to resolve it directly; you don’t have to keep trying to arrange an informal meeting if it’s going nowhere.

      Consider keeping a dated timeline and copies of your key documents, then ask the BCCM Information and Community Education Unit what formal dispute-resolution step may apply to your particular issue. They can be contacted on 1800 060 119 or through the Queensland Government’s body corporate information page. Because this concerns your car-space rights and substantial levies, a Queensland strata lawyer can also review the records and advise you on options. Please take care of yourself and consider leaning on someone you trust while you work through this.

      READER: I rang the bccm many many times for advice in the last few years to understand what happened now that I fully understand and wants to resolve it as I do have evidence the committee and the body corporate manager don’t want to correspond with me and the body corporate manager told me that she removed my historic records to stop my constant emails. she also told me that they don’t have the resolution without dissent that I asked for. What do I do now and where do I go. I can’t afford a lawyer and have no one to lean on

      FLAT CHATBOT: I’m really sorry you’re facing this without support. You’ve already tried speaking with BCCM; the next step may be to ask them about a formal process, rather than keep trying to resolve it through the manager. Put your request in writing to the body corporate (address it to the committee or secretary), keep a copy, and ask how you can inspect the records relating to the car-space right, the relevant resolution and contribution schedule. Note the manager’s statements about removed records and the missing resolution, with dates and any supporting emails or documents.

      Then contact the BCCM Information and Community Education Unit again—by its online enquiry service or on 1800 060 119—and ask which dispute-resolution application fits these facts, what evidence to attach, and what fees or fee assistance may be available. The Queensland Government page links to current forms and dispute-service fees. Flat Chat’s article about unreliable strata records is from 2019 and includes supplied commentary, so treat it only as background—not current legal guidance.

      Because this concerns property rights and levies, ask the Queensland government service about lower-cost support or referral options; I can’t confirm from the information here whether you qualify for fee assistance.

      READER: Where else can I go for help as the chairman has my exclusive car space and I am the one paying high contribution because of that car space. If she removes the historic records if I engage a lawyer to review the records he might not find anything

      FLAT CHATBOT: I’m sorry—you shouldn’t have to rely on the manager’s files alone. Keep your own dated copies of emails, title and sale documents, plans, levy notices and any evidence of the parking allocation. Ask the body corporate in writing for a formal records inspection and copies, and clearly identify the records sought; keep proof of the request and any response. The Queensland BCCM service can explain the current records-access and dispute-resolution process: online enquiry or 1800 060 119. Ask about fees and any lower-cost support options.

      You could also contact the Unit Owners Association of Queensland to ask whether it can point you to owner support. Flat Chat’s article on unreliable strata records is from 2019 and includes supplied commentary, so it’s background only—not proof of what happened in your scheme.

      If you later consult a lawyer, ask whether they can review your own documents and advise on obtaining or preserving the body corporate records. I can’t determine from here whether the chair’s use of the space or your contribution amount is valid. Given the property and levy implications, seek advice from the BCCM service or a Queensland strata lawyer before taking formal steps. General information only, not legal advice.

      READER: The chairman has 3 exclusive car space rights which is showing in the current cms but in the historic cms he only had 1 exclusive car space and his contribution entitlements stayed the same. I can see that very clearly and it could be that he is preventing the body corporate manager to corespondent with me

      FLAT CHATBOT: That difference between the historic and current CMS is worth documenting, but it doesn’t by itself establish how or when the exclusive-use rights changed—or that the chair is directing the manager not to reply. Keep copies of both CMS versions and note their dates and where they came from.

      Send a concise written request to the body corporate (for the committee or secretary), asking for the records supporting the change, including the relevant by-law or resolution, meeting minutes, and contribution schedule. Keep proof of the request and response. Ask Queensland’s BCCM service about the current formal records-access and dispute-resolution steps: online enquiry or 1800 060 119. Because this involves property rights and levies, consider getting independent Queensland strata-law advice if possible.

      READER: Who can I get to review the records and show the truth so I can get my exclusive car space rights back as I am still paying for it through my contribution entitlements being very high

      FLAT CHATBOT: I’m sorry you’re carrying this largely on your own. A Queensland strata lawyer is best placed to review the registered documents and body corporate records and explain your options; a records review can clarify the evidence, but I can’t promise it will restore the car-space right or change your contribution entitlements.

      Since you can’t afford a lawyer, ask the Queensland BCCM Information and Community Education Unit for current low-cost legal or community-support referrals and what formal records-access or dispute-resolution step may fit. You can use its online enquiry service or call 1800 060 119; its guidance and dispute services are described in Flat Chat’s state-by-state guide, which is older, so confirm current details directly with BCCM. Keep copies of your own documents and clearly list the specific records you need reviewed.

      READER: The BCCM they advised me to get the resolution without dissent but the body corporate manager told me she searched and it does not exist so that explains that the removal is invalid and unlawful

      FLAT CHATBOT: I can see why you’re concerned, but the manager not finding a resolution without dissent doesn’t, by itself, prove the change was invalid or unlawful. The key question is what approval and records were legally required for that particular change, and whether other records or a registered by-law support it.

      Ask BCCM what specific records and approvals to check, and whether the absence of that resolution is enough to take a formal dispute-resolution step. Keep the manager’s statement and your dated copies of both CMS versions. Because this affects property rights and levies, don’t treat the missing document alone as a final legal conclusion; seek independent Queensland advice if possible.

      READER: To remove exclusive use car space right from a lot you must have a resolution without dissent passed and the previous owner consenting in writing. That does not exist and the contribution entitlements never adjusted. Is that enough evidence for evidence to return my car space rights

      FLAT CHATBOT: The documents you describe could be important evidence, but I can’t say they are enough to restore your right. Queensland’s guidance says that under the BCCM Act, ending an exclusive-use by-law requires a resolution without dissent and the benefiting lot owner’s written agreement or personal vote; the change takes effect when the new CMS is recorded. So the missing approval and unchanged contribution entitlements are relevant, but a records review must also establish which Act applies, what the registered CMS and by-law say, and whether any valid reallocation or later registration occurred.

      Keep copies of the historic and current CMS, your title and purchase documents, levy notices, and the manager’s written response that the resolution cannot be found. Ask BCCM to confirm the applicable requirements and formal next step, or seek a community legal service or Queensland strata-law advice if available. The Queensland Government’s exclusive-use by-law guidance explains the rules; Flat Chat’s parking dispute article is a 2018 NSW example, not Queensland legal guidance.

      READER: The body corporate manager is being very difficult and ignorance same as the secretary. If I take all my evidence that I have to the lawyer to check them for me how much will that cost me. I am a pensioner can’t afford a lawyer so I feel trapped and paying very high levies which is so unfair

      FLAT CHATBOT: I’m sorry—you’re under real financial pressure. I can’t give a reliable dollar figure: the cost depends on how much material needs reviewing and what advice you ask for. Before booking, ask a Queensland strata lawyer for a written fixed-fee quote for a limited first review of your key documents, and whether they offer a reduced-fee initial appointment or payment options. You could start with the two CMS versions, the relevant correspondence and a short timeline rather than handing over everything at once.

      Since you’re a pensioner, ask the Queensland BCCM Information and Community Education Unit whether it can point you to current free or low-cost legal help; call 1800 060 119. Flat Chat’s article about legal help refers to a NSW centre, so it doesn’t confirm what Queensland assistance is available. Please don’t assume the disputed levies can safely be withheld—check with BCCM or an independent adviser first.

      READER: I did go to the community legal centre but the lawyer was talking very quickly and not even allowing me to show him all the evidence and was a bit dismissive I was very hurt

      FLAT CHATBOT: I’m sorry—that sounds hurtful, especially after you’ve worked so hard to gather the evidence. You deserved to feel heard.

      If you’re willing, you could ask the centre for another appointment with a different lawyer, explaining that you need time to present the key documents and have the advice given slowly. To make the limited time easier, take a one-page timeline and a short list of your main questions, plus the most important documents; ask whether they can review further material or refer you elsewhere if they can’t.

      READER: I was very hurt and didn’t feel he wants to help me as he did not give me the chance to even show him everything I have as evidence. I felt unheard. Our building need a big overhaul on everything about car spaces as there is a lot of corruptions

      FLAT CHATBOT: I’m sorry—you felt unheard at a moment when you were trying to explain something important. It’s understandable to feel frustrated, but I can’t determine whether corruption has occurred from what’s been shared.

      If you choose to try the community legal centre again, you could ask whether another lawyer can give you time to explain the issue, and whether you may bring a support person. A one-page timeline and a few key documents may help keep the appointment focused; you can ask if they’ll consider the rest of your evidence afterwards. You don’t have to tackle a building-wide car-space review on your own—BCCM can explain the formal options for your individual concern.

      READER: Thank you I just give up there is no justice in this world. I feel so opressed and unheard by the body corporate manager, the committee and even the community lawyer was dismissive and I don’t have money to hire a strata lawyer so I just give up and be devastated. No justice in strata

      FLAT CHATBOT: I’m really sorry you feel so unheard and alone. You don’t have to solve the strata issue tonight—please focus on getting support for you. When you say you’re giving up, are you thinking about hurting yourself, or are you in immediate danger? If yes, call 000 now or Lifeline on 13 11 14, and if you can, stay with someone you trust. If you’re safe, please tell someone you trust how overwhelmed you feel; we can take the strata problem one small step at a time.

      READER: Thank you I have to go, I am too stressed

      FLAT CHATBOT: Of course—please go and take a break. You don’t need to deal with any of this right now. If you feel unsafe or might hurt yourself, call 000 or Lifeline on 13 11 14, and if possible let someone you trust know how you’re feeling. You can come back when you’re ready.

      If you want to be alerted when anyone replies to your posts or responds to this topic, please register and login, then you will be able to subscribe to the topic. The opinions offered in these Forum posts and replies are not intended to be taken as legal advice. Readers with serious issues should consult experienced strata lawyers. NB: Longer threads may spill over to additional pages - look for the numbers on the bottom right, under the last post.
    Reply To: The question that almost broke the Chatbot
    PLEASE ... If your property is not in NSW, mention its location (state). Don't identify companies or individuals by name. Don't mention or promote your company or services. Keep acronyms and initials to a minimum. Please, don’t use “quote” unless there is a specific point to which you wish to refer, then highlight (define) that specific passage before you click on "quote". Otherwise just use reply. THANKS.

    You can use BBCodes to format your content.
    Your account can't use all available BBCodes, they will be stripped before saving.

    Your information:




    › Forums › Common Property › Current Page